Will Smith’s Comeback Album Based On A True Story Struggles to Chart Amid Harsh Reviews and Low Sales
Will Smith’s return to music has not gone as planned. His long-awaited comeback album Based On A True Story is reportedly failing to chart on any major Billboard rankings in the United States — a career first for the rapper-turned-Hollywood-giant.
Despite being his first full-length project in nearly two decades, the album did not make it onto the Billboard 200, marking a stark contrast from Smith’s earlier musical achievements. Three out of his previous four studio albums — including Big Willie Style and Willennium — debuted in the Billboard 200’s top 10.
The commercial underperformance extends beyond the U.S., with reports from the United Kingdom revealing that Based On A True Story sold fewer than 300 copies in its debut week.
When the news was shared on X (formerly Twitter) by The Art of Dialogue, fans were quick to share their theories on why the album flopped. “Can’t just unretire after 20 years and expect people to rock with the music. Still a legend tho,” one user commented. Another added, “I do believe he should’ve promoted the album more, dropped singles first instead of a freestyle but I’m sure Will just dropped an album for the hell of it.”
Critical Reception Hasn’t Helped
On top of its poor commercial performance, Based On A True Story has been met with overwhelmingly negative reviews from critics. Pitchfork gave the album a scathing 2.4 out of 10, with writer Stephen Kearse calling it a “pointless apology tour” and labeling it “corny.” Rolling Stone echoed the sentiment, with Mankaprr Conteh describing the project as “clunky” and disjointed.
Much of the album revolves around Smith’s personal journey following the infamous Oscars slap incident involving comedian Chris Rock. Smith addresses the moment and its fallout in multiple tracks, seemingly in an attempt to offer his side of the story and seek redemption.
However, not everyone appreciates the effort — especially not Chris Rock’s family. When approached by TMZ, Tony Rock, Chris’ brother, didn’t hold back. “This album is probably shtty as fck because I haven’t heard anything about it other than ‘Oh, he addresses your brother.’ If that’s the only selling point, that’s a sh*tty album,” he said, making it clear he had no plans to listen to it.
A Misstep in a Legendary Career?
For a star who once dominated both the charts and the box office, Based On A True Story is a rare misstep. While Will Smith’s legacy as a trailblazing entertainer is firmly cemented, this latest venture shows that not even the most recognizable names are immune to the evolving demands of the music industry — especially after a lengthy hiatus.
Whether or not Smith decides to continue pursuing music in the wake of the album’s lukewarm reception remains to be seen. But for now, Based On A True Story serves as a sobering reminder that comebacks require more than star power — they demand timing, strategy, and a message people want to hear.
